Skip to content

Why Quality Joinery Is Worth Every Penny

Keith Dowley of Ultimate Joinery Solutions joins Aaron Worrall to explain why cheaper joinery quotes rarely cover the same work, why timber needs ventilation rather than sealing, and how to choose a joiner you can trust.

Episode
No. 5
Published
Length
1 hr 29 min
Guest
Keith Dowley, Ultimate Joinery Solutions

This episode on

What this episode covers

Good joinery shapes the spaces we use every day, from kitchens and staircases to timber windows and doors, but materials, prices and workmanship all vary, and it is not always obvious who to trust or what you are paying for. In Episode 5 of The Healthy House Podcast, Aaron Worrall is joined by Keith Dowley of Ultimate Joinery Solutions to talk about traditional craftsmanship, how timber behaves in a building, and how to choose a joiner.

From a timber yard at 13 to Ultimate Joinery Solutions

Keith’s route began with work experience in a timber yard at 13, followed by an apprenticeship in cabinet making and college courses in bench joinery and machinery. He says colleges used to teach joinery from the ground up, starting with planing a piece of timber square by hand, but are now largely set up to pass people through for new-build work. After years in shopfitting and the new-build industry he left with three weeks of work lined up and started Ultimate Joinery Solutions from the back of a van with his son. Most early work came from reputation, then from LinkedIn and the construction networking group Grafters, where a call for help led to a long job. A later bespoke project in Cheshire is what prompted him to rent a workshop.

Traditional joinery and box sash windows

Keith’s team makes the full range, from simple opening windows to traditional box sashes, which have cords, pulleys and weights. Few people make them now, he says, because of the cost and the craftsmanship they need. His team refurbishes windows from the 18th and 19th centuries that still work, and he argues that a traditionally made timber window can last far longer than a plastic one, provided it is looked after.

That upkeep is the catch. Timber is, in Keith’s words, a living organism. Stop repainting it and the paint blisters and the timber rots, and the pair say people often rip out old windows and fit plastic simply because plastic needs nothing doing to it. Keith gives a conservation-area example: a box sash had been taken out and replaced with a plastic replica, and because the house is in a conservation area it has to be put back as it was. The pair agree that many people do not understand how conservation areas work.

Timber needs air

Ventilation is the point that comes back through the episode. The pair describe a suspended timber floor that should have had air bricks front and rear. The rear ones had been blocked by rabbit hutches and a concrete slab, so it had ventilation only at the front, and the damage was phenomenal, on a lovely floor. Wood will last for ever if it stays in the right conditions, they say, and the trouble starts when people do not maintain it or do something unwise. Keith’s checklist answer is that too many people now seal everything up, including air bricks, and that timber needs the right ventilation. They agree that maintenance is a large part of looking after a building, and that many people do not realise they have that responsibility.

Choosing the right timber

Keith avoids softwood for joinery, because fast-grown softwood moves and twists, and prefers hardwood for windows and doors. For structural timber, he says the standard C16 grade is fine for stud walls in principle, but he tends to use C24 even there because it is straighter. C16 can come bent like a banana, particularly if it has sat outside damp and then dries out indoors. In new builds this causes problems: a warped stud wall can stop a tiler working, so the plaster has to come down and be redone. Many house builders now use metal studs, which do not move or rot, though Aaron thinks that creates its own problems. Both agree that what you cannot see, such as foundations and the timber behind the plaster, can be the biggest problem.

Why bespoke costs what it does

Bespoke, Keith says, means there is nothing standard about it. He will make anything a client can draw or think of, and the more unusual, the better he likes it. His examples include an oak waterfall-edge desk with mitred corners so the grain flows through, and drinks trolleys, pastry trolleys, a waiter station and a DJ booth for hospitality clients, along with counters for convenience stores.

The price follows the labour. A traditional box sash takes more than a week of one joiner’s time before it goes for priming, and the business also pays for insurance, pensions, energy and keeping machines running. Keith’s approach with clients is to be honest and upfront about cost, and he says people wanting something special generally know it will not be cheap.

Choosing a joiner and comparing quotes

Domestic joinery is, Keith says, largely unregulated: the only qualifications most joiners hold come from college, and after that it is a free-for-all. For a homeowner that means it is hard to know whether someone can do the job until a deposit has been paid. His advice is to ask for case studies of projects from start to finish and not just finished photos, since anyone can take a picture from the internet, and to rely on reputation and previous work. A joiner should also be able to read a drawing.

On quotes, the pair agree that a cheaper price is rarely for the same job. If someone says they can get it cheaper, the question is cheaper than what, and what is actually included. They say that you can have quality and fast, or cheap and fast, or quality and cheap but slow, and not all three. Keith’s final advice is not to take the cheapest quote, which will come back and bite you.

Skills, apprentices and the future of the trade

Keith thinks skills are being lost with each generation and says few firms take apprentices on, partly because of health and safety and HR. He would encourage a young person into the trade, but says to learn a craft first rather than falling into new-build work. His own difficulty is that there is no college course for what he does, so he cannot take on an apprentice through the usual route. He is also a believer in educating homeowners, including the growing number of younger buyers of older homes, who need to learn how to look after them.

Fire doors and accreditation

Keith is working towards Constructionline Gold so that Ultimate Joinery Solutions can work with larger clients, and towards accreditation to install, maintain and sign off fire doors. He explains why this matters: a third party can certify a responsible person, but the people actually fitting the door need to be trained too, so he intends to have everyone who works on the doors trained. He says the importance of getting fire doors right is a heavy responsibility, because if the work is not done and documented properly someone’s life can be at risk.

AI and bespoke work

Keith says he starts a price with AI because it is quicker, but you still have to cast your eye over it because it does not know everything. The pair say customers sometimes arrive with a price from an AI chatbot or a website, which does not include fitting it. Aaron says Pinterest now has AI-generated images of things that cannot be built because they are not structurally sound, and that people ask whether they can be made. He is not worried about AI in his own trade and wonders whether it will ever pick up a drill or use a bench saw, and both say people will still want to deal with people.

The Healthy House Checklist

Every episode ends with the Healthy House Checklist. Keith’s answer is about learning to live and work with timber. Do not seal everything up, including air bricks, because timber needs proper ventilation. Protect windows and doors, for example by painting them. And do your background checks on whoever you hire, whatever the trade, because the cheapest quote will always come back and bite you. He adds that timber durability ratings come from burying samples in the ground and seeing how long they last.

Who should listen

This episode is for anyone planning joinery work, from a single bespoke piece to repair or replacement of period windows, as well as tradespeople developing their craft or thinking about growing a construction business of their own.

Questions this episode answers

How do I choose a good joiner for bespoke work?

Keith Dowley says reputation and previous work are the best guide, because domestic joinery is largely unregulated and the only qualifications most joiners hold come from college. Ask to see previous projects and for case studies that show a job from start to finish, not just a finished photo, since anyone can pull a picture off the internet. A firm taking on a joiner for a project can tell within the first day if they are any good, he says, but a homeowner usually only finds out after a deposit has been paid, so do your background checks first.

Why does timber need ventilation?

The pair say timber lasts for a very long time if it stays in the right conditions, and ventilation is a big part of that. Their example is a suspended timber floor with air bricks front and rear, where the rear air bricks had been blocked by rabbit hutches and a concrete slab down the side, leaving ventilation only at the front. Suspended floors need cross-ventilation, and the damage from losing it was described as phenomenal. Keith Dowley adds that too many people now seal up air bricks, windows and doors.

Can traditional box sash windows be repaired instead of replaced?

Yes, according to Keith Dowley, whose team refurbishes windows from the 18th and 19th centuries that still work. A traditional box sash has cords, pulleys and weights, whereas many modern sashes use a coil, and Keith says few people make traditional ones now because of the cost and the skill needed. Timber windows need more maintenance than plastic ones because, as he puts it, timber is a living organism, so they have to be kept painted and protected.

Are timber windows better than plastic ones?

Keith Dowley argues that traditionally made timber windows can last far longer than plastic ones if they are looked after, and that plastic windows need no maintenance but are not something that will last for centuries. He is clear that timber needs upkeep: stop repainting and it will rot. The pair say many people replace old windows with plastic because they know they will not have to do anything to them, though Keith says that for certain houses you simply would not.

Why is bespoke joinery expensive?

Keith Dowley says the price mostly comes from the labour. A piece takes a skilled person a long time to make, and a traditional box sash window takes more than a week of one joiner's time before it even goes for priming. On top of that the business pays for insurance, pensions, energy, running the machines and keeping them maintained. He says the best approach with clients is to be honest and upfront about cost, and that people who want something bespoke generally know it will not be cheap.

Which timber should be used for windows, doors and stud walls?

Keith Dowley avoids softwood for joinery, because fast-grown softwood will move and twist, and prefers hardwood for windows and doors. For stud walls he tends to use the stronger C24 structural grade instead of C16, because it comes straighter, whereas C16 can bend like a banana, especially if it has sat outside damp before being used. In new builds he says warped studwork can mean pulling down plaster before tiling can go on. He also notes that many house builders now use metal studs, which do not move or rot.

Do I need permission to replace sash windows in a conservation area?

The episode does not set out the rules, but its example shows you cannot assume you can change them. Keith Dowley describes a job where a box sash window had been taken out and replaced with a plastic replica, and because the house is in a conservation area it has to be put back as it was. The pair say many people do not understand how conservation areas work, so check before you replace windows.

Can AI price or design joinery?

Keith Dowley says AI is a quick way to start a price, but you still have to cast your eye over it because it does not know everything. The pair say customers sometimes arrive with a figure from an AI chatbot or a website, which does not cover the fitting. Aaron Worrall adds that Pinterest now carries AI-generated images of things that cannot physically be built or are not structurally sound, and that people still ask whether they can be made, at a price.

What should I do to protect timber in my home?

Keith Dowley's advice is to learn to live and work with timber. Do not seal up air bricks and give it proper ventilation, and protect windows and doors by keeping them painted. He says timber durability ratings come from burying samples in the ground and seeing how long they last, and that treated and maintained timber is a straightforward material to look after. He also warns against the cheapest quote, which he says is cheap for a reason.

Who is Keith Dowley?

Keith Dowley is the owner of Ultimate Joinery Solutions and the guest on Episode 5 of The Healthy House Podcast. He started with work experience in a timber yard at 13, then trained through a cabinet-making apprenticeship and college, before years in shopfitting and the new-build industry. He left new builds with three weeks of work booked and started Ultimate Joinery Solutions from the back of a van with his son, and now runs a workshop and is working towards fire door accreditation.