Skip to content

Before You Build: The Advice That Could Save You Thousands

How do you know if you’re paying the right price for your building project? In Episode 9 of The Healthy House Podcast, Aaron is joined by Fiona Hull from Construction Q to explore how quantity surveying can help homeowners and contractors manage costs, avoid disputes and…

Episode
No. 9
Published
Length
1 hr 21 min
Guest
Fiona Hull, Construction Q

This episode on

What this episode covers

How do you know whether the price on your building project is the right one? In episode nine of The Healthy House Podcast, host Aaron Worrall talks to Fiona Hull, owner of Construction Q, a quantity surveying practice, about what a quantity surveyor (QS) does and how cost advice at the start of a job helps homeowners and contractors compare prices, understand contracts and avoid disputes.

It is a long conversation. It starts with how Fiona set up her business and what a QS does, moves through the practical advice for anyone about to hire a builder or sign a contract, and then turns to AI, young people entering construction, networking and the charity work Fiona is known for.

What a quantity surveyor does, and how Construction Q began

Fiona describes the job as being the accountant in the construction industry and the project manager. A QS deals with budgets and costs, paying the teams on site, sometimes buying the materials, and the legal side, including contracts. Her mother used to say that QSs count bricks. Most people have never heard of the role, Fiona says, and that is her biggest headache: people see a fee, not a way of saving money.

Fiona was a QS with a main contractor when she left to set up Construction Q in 2010, working from her spare bedroom. A contractor she used to work for gave her two days a week, and a homeowner doing renovations wanted a QS, so she had clients from the start. The business has grown by taking on a member of staff roughly every year, and it now does a lot of commercial work, including schools, alongside high-end domestic jobs. Fiona’s description of her approach is simple: she tries to be fair. She says a private-practice QS usually acts for the client, whereas a main contractor’s QS acts for the contractor, and that her background on the contractor side helps her know what to look for.

Price the job before it goes to tender

Fiona’s main message to homeowners is to get an independent price before you ask for quotes. Without somebody telling you what the job should cost, she says, you cannot know that the firms you have asked are giving the best price, so choosing the cheapest of three can still mean paying too much. She says architects are not trained on the numbers or on what the bricks should cost, so a QS spots things that an architect comparing tenders for a client may not, and she is quick to say she loves the architects she works with. She describes a recent job where the QS had not been employed, the client was over budget and was about to go with the cheapest builder, and once she had standardised the prices a large error turned up that nobody had noticed.

Scope and provisional sums

The biggest problem in comparing prices is the scope. If it has not been clearly defined, every builder prices something slightly different. Electrics are the example Fiona gives. At planning-drawing stage nobody can say what the rewire will cost, particularly if audio-visual is being added, so a provisional sum goes into the tender. One builder may put in a far lower figure than another, and without a QS explaining what it means, the client and architect may simply go with the low number. A provisional sum, she says, is exactly what you pick, so as you go round each room and add what you want it can end up far higher. In a tender comparison provisional sums should be standardised so every bid is the same, and she says clients dealing direct tend to see the number and assume it is a fixed price.

Contracts, deposits and payment terms

On smaller domestic jobs Fiona says the usual problem is no defined scope and no clear contract. A quote followed by an instruction to go ahead and a payment is a form of contract, but it is not the standard construction contract a QS can use to administer the job and value the work. On larger projects there is usually a JCT contract. She is a fan of simplified contracts for homeowners, because there is no point in over-complicating things with legal jargon, but she says even a smaller project needs a contract that is clear on programme, payment terms and what happens in a dispute.

She is blunt about deposits. She has seen homeowners pay out a big sum up front because the builder asked, with no contract setting out the payment terms, and then the builder has gone into administration. Builders often work to a set routine of stage payments, which can bear no relation to how far the project has got and usually suits the builder more than the client. If a client then realises that a large share has been paid and not much has been built, they may withhold money, which is awkward for a builder who has always worked that way. So, she says, it is in everybody’s interests to have a QS.

When it goes wrong

Fiona says Construction Q is often brought in to try to agree a job at the end, when a dispute has already started, usually towards the final account. By then, she says, the client has run out of money and the builder is desperate for it, so the last thing she wants to do is charge a huge fee. Contracts are a whole job in themselves, she says. If the wrong set of drawings goes into the contract, the contractor may be due extra money, and it is the client, who employed a professional team to pull the contract together, who loses out. On larger jobs Construction Q can run adjudications itself and works with a law firm when a claim needs to go further. Fiona describes the QS as a bit like an insurance policy: hopefully nothing goes wrong, but if it does, you can fall back on the contract about who gets what and who is liable.

Advice for contractors and subcontractors

For commercial work, Fiona says, the first rule is to read the contract. If a thick one arrives that you do not understand, do not sign it: draft in a QS practice to review it and push back on unfair terms. Read the whole tender pack, because there is a reason the client sent so many documents and something in there could trip you up. Review the scope and make sure your price is right. Then check the payment terms and how long you wait, the retention that will be held back, the programme, because missing set dates can mean damages, and clauses such as unlimited visits to site, which leave you carrying the cost of going back each time. She also warns against winning a large contract without allowing for site set-up, cabins and inspections: that is how a firm becomes a busy fool.

Telling a good contractor from a bad one

Aaron asks how Fiona tells a good tradesperson from one she would avoid. For her it is about how somebody conducts themselves, not only the work. If someone does not ring back, answer emails or act professionally on the admin side, what will the trade side look like? Fiona and Aaron agree that quotes written on the back of a sheet of paper are common practice, and Fiona says a tender comparison without a QS can have one of those next to a polished document produced by a program from a set of plans.

AI and experience

The conversation moves to AI. Aaron says he thinks it will be like electricity, something we will have to live with, but that the worry is people getting lazy and trusting it too much, and he expects it to create jobs because people will have to check it. Fiona agrees there is a use for it. Construction Q uses it daily and she is not scared of it, but she says it will not replace what is in an experienced QS’s head: the databases help, yet a lot of pricing comes from experience, and every building is unique. She describes online services that turn a set of plans into a price and a thorough-looking document, but says unless the building is a square box the price will be wrong. A bill of quantities, once measured by hand from the drawings, is now done with software, which she stresses is not AI and is still operated by the QS. Both say that if AI misses something, the responsibility is still yours.

Young people, apprenticeships and careers

Fiona fell into quantity surveying: a university offered her a commercial management and quantity surveying course with a contractor sponsor, which she describes as accounting and business in the construction industry. She now lectures to architecture students at a university school, partly to teach them to design with cost in mind, and Construction Q always has apprentices, whom she makes do things the old way to learn. For work experience she takes students round a planning consultant, an architect, a CGI studio, a heritage contractor and a main contractor, because her message is that everybody could work in construction whatever their interests. She calls the idea that it is for people without A levels or who will not earn much bonkers.

On getting in, her advice is to make personal contact, pick up the phone, and tell small businesses what you want, since they are often more open than big schemes with set forms. She replies personally to every apprenticeship application and points people to other practices. She says rising minimum wage costs make it hard for small firms to take on apprentices, though she supports the increase. Fiona says sites are far more pleasant than when she trained, and that better facilities help attract a more diverse workforce and mixed teams.

Networking, culture and giving back

Fiona says networking started the business, but she is no longer a fan of the large national group she used. She treats everybody the same and says some of her best jobs came through a florist. Construction Q hosts its own quarterly informal networking lunch for the construction industry. She wants people to be fair, pays trades promptly because she knows cash flow matters, and likes an office with people together so that younger staff hear the problems and the older ones bounce solutions off each other.

Construction Q has always done free work for charities, usually one large project a year, including a respite centre and a children’s hospice. Fiona is also one of the organisers of a December trolley dash for Cash for Kids, where construction firms with branded trolleys race round a store, opened early by a retailer, filling them with toys for the Mission Christmas appeal.

The Healthy House Checklist

Asked for her tips, Fiona gives three: scope it, price it and stick to it. Be clear what you are asking for or what your price includes. Price it correctly, whichever side you are on. Then stick to it, because changes further down the line are where the extra costs come in. If you spent the time up front getting the design and the scope right, you do not have to change it.

Who should listen

Anyone about to compare builders’ quotes or sign a contract for building work, and any small contractor or subcontractor who wants to understand the cost and contract side before taking on a larger job. It is also worth a listen for anyone thinking about a career or an apprenticeship in construction.

Questions this episode answers

What does a quantity surveyor do, and when should I hire one?

A quantity surveyor, or QS, is as Fiona Hull puts it the accountant in the construction industry and the project manager: they deal with the budgets and costs, paying the teams on site, sometimes buying the materials, and the contracts. Fiona says that if you employ a QS at the outset they will end up saving you money over the project, and that this is the point most people miss because they see the QS only as a fee. A QS can help both homeowners and subcontractors or main contractors.

Is the cheapest builder's quote the best one?

Not necessarily, because without an independent price you cannot tell whether the cheapest of your quotes is any good. Fiona Hull says that if nobody has independently priced the job before tender, you cannot know that the firms you went to are giving the best price, and that comparing quotes is hard anyway because the scope is often not clearly defined. She describes a recent job where the client was going ahead with the cheapest builder and, once the prices were standardised, a large error had gone unspotted.

What is a provisional sum in a builder's quote?

A provisional sum is a placeholder allowance in a quote for work whose cost cannot yet be known, such as the electrics on a project that has only planning drawings, and it is not a fixed price. Fiona Hull says one builder may put in a much lower provisional sum than another, and that without a QS explaining what it means a client and architect may simply see the low number and go for it. She says provisional sums should be standardised so every tender is compared like for like, and that the final cost depends on what you actually choose room by room.

Do I need a contract for building work?

Yes, says Fiona Hull, because without a proper construction contract scope and payment terms are not defined. She explains that a quote followed by a go-ahead and a payment is a form of contract, but not a standard one that can be used to administer the job and value the work. Larger projects usually use a JCT contract, and she is a fan of the simplified forms made for homeowners, because there is no point in loading a domestic project with legal jargon. She stresses that even a smaller project needs a contract that is clear on programme, payment terms and what happens in a dispute.

What are the most common mistakes that lead to disputes with a builder?

Fiona Hull says the most common one is not having a defined scope, so starting without a clear contract that says what is being provided for the price. She says disputes at the smaller end usually surface towards the final account, when the homeowner does not want to pay more and the builder thinks they are owed it. Wrong drawings in the contract can also hand a contractor extra money, so the client loses out even though they employed a professional team.

Is it safe to pay a builder a large deposit up front?

Fiona Hull describes it as a risk: she has seen homeowners pay out a huge chunk before work began because the builder asked, and in some cases the builder has then gone into administration. She says a builder without a QS on the job often uses a set routine of stage payments, with a percentage up front and more at set points, that can bear no relation to how far the project has got, and that this usually suits the builder more than the client. Her answer is to agree a construction contract that sets out the programme, payment terms and what happens in a dispute.

What should a contractor check before signing a commercial contract?

Read the contract, and do not sign a thick one you do not understand, says Fiona Hull. She says to have a QS practice review it and push back on any unfair terms, and to read the whole tender pack, because there is a reason the client sent so many documents and something in there could trip you up. Check the scope against your price, the payment terms and how long you wait, the retention that will be held back, the programme (missing set dates can mean damages) and anything like unlimited visits to site, which can leave you carrying repeated mobilisation costs.

How can I tell a good tradesperson or contractor from a bad one?

Fiona Hull says you can tell an awful lot from how somebody conducts themselves, not just from viewing their work. If a person does not ring back, does not answer emails or is not professional on the admin side, she asks what the trade side of the business will look like. She and Aaron also say that quotes written on the back of a sheet of paper are common practice.

Can AI replace a quantity surveyor?

Fiona Hull does not think so, although she says Construction Q uses AI daily and is not scared of it. She says it can help with office processes, but that pricing rests on what is in a QS's head, that every building is unique, and that software which turns plans into a price will be wrong unless the building is a square box, however thorough the document looks. She and Aaron agree that the responsibility for checking its work stays with you.

Who is Fiona Hull?

Fiona Hull is a quantity surveyor and the owner of Construction Q, the guest on Episode 9 of The Healthy House Podcast. She worked as a QS for a main contractor before setting up Construction Q in her spare bedroom in 2010, with a first client she already knew from her contractor days and a homeowner doing renovations. The practice has grown by taking on staff over the years, does a lot of commercial work now, and has won awards. Fiona also does pro bono work for charities and helps run a trolley-dash fundraiser for Cash for Kids.

What are Fiona Hull's Healthy House Checklist tips?

Fiona Hull's advice for any project, whatever its size, is to scope it, price it and stick to it. Scope it by being clear what you are asking for, or what your price includes, so there is no ambiguity later. Price it correctly, on whichever side you are on. Then stick to it, because changes further down the line are where the extra costs come in; if you spent the time up front getting the design and scope right, you do not have to change it.