Brick by Brick: The Truth About Traditional Homes
Heritage masonry specialist Jake Mitchell of Archer Brick & Stone joins Aaron Worrall to explain why lime mortar, not cement, is essential to protecting traditional brick and stone homes.
- Episode
- No. 2
- Published
- Length
- 1 hr 32 min
- Guest
- Jake Mitchell, Archer Brick & Stone
This episode on
What this episode covers
The mortar between your bricks is not something most homeowners ever think about, until it starts to fail. In episode two of The Healthy House Podcast, host Aaron Worrall talks to heritage masonry specialist Jake Mitchell of Archer Brick & Stone about why the materials used to repair a traditional building matter as much as the skill of the person doing the work.
Jake is from Boston, Massachusetts, where he worked on brick and stone restoration, and he now works on traditional buildings in the UK, where he says his biggest learning curve was working out why so many buildings have damp problems. Much of the episode is a plain-English lesson in lime, with practical advice on contractors, paint, conservation areas and what to check at home.
Why cement pointing damages old brick and stone
Aaron describes pointing as the sacrificial part of a building, the part that is meant to wear away first so the brick or stone does not. Jake’s argument is that cement pointing turns this upside down. Cement is harder and less permeable than traditional brick and stone, so it stops water leaving the wall. If the pointing is harder than the brick, he says, it is the brick that effectively fails.
The sign he looks for is spalled brick, where the face flakes away. It shows a brick that is wet and absorbing moisture like a sponge, with no way to wring itself out. Add freezing and thawing and the trapped water expands and contracts, popping mortar joints and blowing the face off brick or stone. On one railway arch job, he says, decades of strong cement repairs meant that removing a damaged brick pulled the face off the sound bricks around it. Jake tells customers that damp in the house is only a matter of when it shows.
This is not an argument against cement everywhere. Jake says cement is brilliant for foundations, skyscrapers, modern buildings and cavity walls, and that on some exposed coastal sites a stronger mortar can help. The problem is using it on traditional solid-wall buildings. And a stronger mortar does not make a house stand up: the pointing is not what is holding it together.
Lime explained: from limestone to mortar
Jake walks through how lime is made. Limestone, which is calcium carbonate, is crushed and burned in a kiln. That drives off the carbon dioxide and leaves quicklime. Adding water to quicklime is called slaking, and it gives off heat, which is where the name hot lime comes from. A hot lime mix is slaked together with sand (aggregate), so it can be used as mortar, while lime putty is slaked without aggregate and can be kept sealed under water for a long time. Lime is naturally sticky and workable, which is why it is described as self-plasticising.
Hot lime and lime putty are air limes. They set by carbonation, taking carbon dioxide back from the air, so that in Jake’s telling the end result is limestone again. That can take months, if not years, to fully dry.
Natural hydraulic limes (NHL) are made from limestone or chalk that contains impurities such as clay, and they are burned at a higher temperature. Those impurities react and bond when water is present, so the mortar begins to set as the wall is built, which is why NHLs became popular. They come in grades such as NHL 2, 3.5 and 5, from weaker to stronger. Jake calls NHL 3.5 a popular mid-range choice, but the pair agree that the top people in the industry do not all agree on which grade suits which job.
Hydrated lime, often sold as builders’ lime, is dried-out lime putty. It has lost its binding strength on its own and was traditionally added to cement mortar to make it easier to work. Jake loves both hot lime mixes and NHLs and has never had a problem with either. His point is to pick the right tool for the job.
As Aaron says, buildings do not have lungs. What people call breathability is permeability: the ability of a wall to take up water and let it evaporate again without it becoming a problem.
Telling lime from cement, and why the finish matters
Jake says he can tell lime and cement apart immediately, though he does not think most trades can. Cement pointing is usually smooth, with a trowelled finish. Lime is not given a trowel finish: smoothing it draws moisture to the surface too quickly, so it cracks as it cures, and because lime shrinks as it dries it needs tamping to close any void behind the joint. The result is a rougher, more rustic look.
A house built before the 1920s will usually have been pointed mostly in lime, he says, although some Victorian houses with a cavity wall or two may have been done in a hybrid mix. Where cement pointing has fallen out, he can often see old lime, aggregate or black ash behind it. Different parts of one house, such as the front, the gable and the chimney, can need different mortars because of how exposed they are.
Paint, render and lime wash
Paint and render get the same treatment as cement pointing. Aaron’s image is of wrapping a house up like a can of pop: we put moisture into our homes all the time by breathing, bathing and cooking, and if it cannot escape it will build up and cause damage somewhere. Jake is against non-permeable masonry paint and cement render on traditional buildings, and says both are very hard to remove without damaging the brick or stone beneath. On very porous sandstone, paint can sink so deep that replacing the stone is the better option.
His preferred finish is lime wash, which is lime putty thinned until it can be applied with a brush. It keeps lime against lime, stays vapour permeable and can be tinted with natural pigments. Lime does not repel water, he says. It takes water in and lets it evaporate, without letting it in too far. He also rates silica-based water-repellent clear coats, sometimes called masonry creams, as permeable and very good, and says newer permeable paints are good too, though still in their infancy.
Buying in a conservation area or a listed building
Jake is frank that he finds conservation areas inconsistent. His advice to a buyer is to speak to the conservation or planning officer before signing, so you know what you are allowed to do, and to get any survey from someone who specialises in heritage buildings, who is better placed to judge what restoring the house involves. He illustrates the problem with a street where one house has uPVC windows and the family next door are told to take theirs out. Expect that kind of inconsistency and go in with your eyes open. The same goes for listed buildings, where his motto is to put back the fabric the original building was made from and not do anything fancy.
Choosing a repointing contractor
Jake’s first red flag is a contractor who will not come and look at the job. A photo cannot show a hedge, a fence or the full condition of a wall, so never send photos and expect a quote back. He suggests asking whether the work has a warranty and whether the company is insured, and asking to see examples of previous work or to speak to past customers. Poor workmanship, he and Aaron agree, costs more to fix than the original price would have been, so the cheapest quote is not always the best. Careful detail, such as a neat decorative joint finish, is a good sign that someone cared.
They also agree that work on an older home can be phased. A young family on a budget should be able to ask for the jobs to be broken down and done over time, and Jake describes customers who chose a cheaper company and then found the damage had cost more to put right.
Damp is not always a pointing problem
Not every house with damp needs repointing, Jake says, though repointing sometimes cures it. In one example he describes, the old lime pointing was in good condition and the damp came from a hole cut for a duct with no collar around it. He prefers to see a building in person for that reason.
On a home with mould, his approach is to keep changes minimal and phased. Rather than telling someone to replace their windows, he would suggest an extractor fan and fixing missing flashing first, though he notes that sealed modern windows can slow the natural airflow of a house that was built with single-glazed wooden ones. In newer buildings he looks for simple faults such as missing sealant around a window, insulation foam where it should not be, and cavities full of rubble that can bridge moisture. If a job is outside his experience, he says, he will tell the customer and pass it on rather than guess.
The Healthy House Checklist
Every episode ends with the Healthy House Checklist. Jake’s answer starts with looking over your mortar joints and brickwork whenever you walk around the house. You do not need to know what you are looking at, only whether something is cracked or broken that should not be, and if it worries you, call someone or do your homework. Mortar should not be lying on the ground, and if it is, there is an underlying reason. Then check your gutters for leaves, bird debris and moss. It is his biggest bugbear.
Who should listen
This episode is aimed at anyone who owns, or hopes to own, a Victorian, Edwardian or other older property, as well as buyers weighing up a period home and homeowners who have just been quoted for repointing work. If you have ever wondered whether a quick fix to your brickwork might cause more harm than good, this conversation gives you the grounding to ask better questions before any work begins.
Questions this episode answers
Why is cement pointing bad for old brickwork?
Cement is harder and less permeable than traditional brick and stone, so it traps moisture in the wall instead of letting it evaporate. Pointing is meant to be the sacrificial part of a wall, wearing away before the masonry does. When it is harder than the brick, the brick takes the damage instead: Jake Mitchell describes spalled, sponge-like brick, and freeze-thaw cycles that blow the face off brick or stone. He is not against cement in general, only against using it on traditional buildings.
What is the difference between hot lime, lime putty and NHL lime?
Hot lime and lime putty are air limes, made by burning limestone to make quicklime and then slaking it with water. A hot lime mix is slaked with sand (aggregate) so it can be used as mortar, while lime putty is slaked without aggregate and can be stored sealed under water. Both set slowly by taking carbon dioxide back from the air, and can take months or even years to dry fully. Natural hydraulic limes (NHL) come from limestone containing impurities such as clay, and also set by reacting with water. They come in grades such as NHL 2, 3.5 and 5, from weaker to stronger. Jake Mitchell likes both air limes and NHLs and says the key is picking the right one for the job, adding that experts disagree about which grade suits what.
How can I tell whether my house was pointed in lime or cement?
Jake Mitchell says cement pointing usually has a smooth, trowelled finish, whereas lime is left rougher and more rustic. A house built before the 1920s will usually have been pointed mostly in lime, and where cement pointing has fallen out you can sometimes see old lime mortar, aggregate or black ash behind it. He says he can tell the two apart at a glance but does not think every trade can, so ask a specialist if you are unsure.
What does spalling brick mean?
Spalling is when the face of a brick or stone flakes or peels away. Jake Mitchell says it shows the brick is wet, absorbing moisture like a sponge and unable to dry out. On older buildings a common cause is cement pointing that is harder than the brick and holds water in, followed by repeated freezing and thawing. He tells customers that damp in the house will follow, whether it shows now or years later.
Is it a bad idea to paint old brickwork?
Jake Mitchell is against non-permeable masonry paint on traditional brick and stone. It wraps the wall so moisture cannot escape, and it is very hard to remove without damaging the masonry underneath, particularly very porous sandstone. His preferred alternative is lime wash, which is thinned lime putty applied with a brush, stays vapour permeable and can be tinted with natural pigments. Lime does not repel water; it takes it in and lets it evaporate. He also says silica-based water-repellent clear coats, sometimes called masonry creams, are permeable and very good, and that newer permeable paints are good but still in their infancy.
What should I know before buying in a conservation area or a listed building?
Speak to the conservation officer or planning officer before you sign, so you know what work needs permission. Jake Mitchell says conservation areas can be inconsistent, with one neighbour allowed something that another is told to undo, so go in with your eyes open. He also advises getting any survey from someone who specialises in heritage buildings, because they are better placed to judge what restoring the house will involve. On listed buildings his motto is to put back the fabric the original building was made from rather than do anything fancy.
What are the red flags when hiring a repointing contractor?
Jake Mitchell's first red flag is a contractor who will not visit the job and quotes from photos alone, because a photo cannot show obstructions or the full condition of the wall. He suggests asking whether the work comes with a warranty and whether the company is insured, and asking to see examples of previous work or to speak to past customers. He also says the cheapest quote is not always the best, because poor workmanship costs more to put right, and that careful detail, such as a neat decorative joint finish, is a sign someone took care.
If I have damp, do I need to repoint?
Not necessarily. Jake Mitchell says not every house with damp needs repointing, although repointing sometimes cures it. Damp can be penetrating damp or condensation among other causes, and he gives an example where the pointing was in good condition and the real problem was a hole cut for a duct with no collar around it. He prefers to see a building in person rather than diagnose from a photo, so that he can spot the real cause and match the right lime.
How can I protect the brickwork on an older home?
Jake Mitchell's low-cost tips are to keep bins and bike sheds away from walls, since anything stacked against a wall stops it drying and, he suggests, bounces rain onto it; to keep gutters clear; to deal with ivy, whose roots can get into cavities and brickwork; and to have cracks looked at, since cracks let moisture in. Step-shaped cracks running from the corners of windows or doors are worth a visit from a specialist. If mortar is lying on the ground there is a reason for it, so find out why.
Who is Jake Mitchell?
Jake Mitchell is a heritage masonry specialist at Archer Brick & Stone. He grew up in Boston, Massachusetts, where he worked in masonry restoration, and now works on traditional buildings in the UK. He joins host Aaron Worrall on Episode 2 to explain why material choice matters so much when repairing older properties.
